Updated: November 2026 | Dubai Livin Property Research
Emaar South vs The Valley is a choice between two of Emaar’s lower-priced communities on opposite sides of Dubai. Emaar South is a golf community of apartments, townhouses and villas next to Al Maktoum International Airport in Dubai South. The Valley is a townhouse and villa community on Dubai-Al Ain Road (E66), with no apartments at all.
Both carry the Emaar name and both sell new homes on similar payment plans. But they suit different budgets, different jobs and different families. This guide compares them on price, what buyers have actually paid, payment plans, construction progress, rents, schools, commutes and risks, using Emaar’s own listings and Dubai Land Department (DLD) records.
Emaar South vs The Valley: the quick verdict
Pick Emaar South if your budget is under AED 2 million, you want an apartment, or you work near Al Maktoum airport, Dubai South or Expo City. It is the cheaper way into an Emaar community and it has a school close by.
Pick The Valley if you want a three- or four-bedroom townhouse or villa, you work in the east or centre of the city, and you can spend about AED 2.5 million or more. Its homes are bigger, its ready resale market is deeper and its villa rents are higher.
Either way, you’ll need a car. Neither community has a metro station, and both score near the bottom of Dubai areas for shops, clinics and schools close to home.
Emaar South vs The Valley side by side
| Factor | Emaar South | The Valley |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Dubai South, beside Al Maktoum International Airport (DWC) | Dubai-Al Ain Road (E66); DLD area Al Yufrah 1 |
| Drive to DWC airport | About 5 km | About 50 km |
| Drive to Expo City Dubai | About 20 km | About 41 km |
| Drive to Downtown Dubai | About 53 km | About 39 km |
| Drive to Dubai Marina | About 38 km | About 53 km |
| Property types | Apartments, townhouses and villas | Townhouses, twin villas and villas. No apartments |
| Emaar “prices from” | AED 1,060,000 (Golf Hills launch price) | AED 1,600,000 (Elora launch price) |
| Cheapest home Emaar lists with live stock | AED 1,906,888 (Golf Trails, 2 to 3 bedrooms) | AED 8,891,888 (Ovelle, 5 bedrooms, the only live listing) |
| Median registered sale, 12 months (DLD) | AED 1.68 million (Emaar’s Emaar South company, 1,567 sales) | AED 3.30 million (606 sales) |
| Median price per sq ft (DLD) | About AED 1,609 | About AED 1,376 |
| Ready 3-bedroom villa, average sale | AED 2.48 million | AED 2.70 million |
| 3-bedroom villa, average Ejari rent | AED 114,365 a year | AED 134,938 a year |
| Gross yield, villas | About 4.3% (apartments about 5.2%) | About 4.9% |
| Payment plan, newest releases | 10/70/20 (Emaar-branded schedules) | 10/70/20 (broker-reported) |
| Newest declared completion dates | 30 Sep 2029 to 31 Oct 2030 | 31 Dec 2028 (Vindera), 31 Dec 2029 (Ovelle) |
| Homes in the DLD registry | 9,171 in 35 projects; 3,455 complete | 9,144 in 28 projects; 2,354 complete |
| Service charges | DLD index median about AED 6.4 per sq ft (5 buildings) | No DLD index entry; broker quotes AED 3 to 4 per sq ft for Avelia |
| Nearest school | GEMS Founders School Dubai South, about 0.9 km from Greenview 1 | None inside; nearest KHDA schools about 11 km away |
| Amenities open today | 18-hole golf course and clubhouse; project pools and gyms | The Valley Pavilion (Monoprix, Bin Sina Pharmacy, Maple Bear nursery) |
| Metro | None; Expo City Dubai station about 20 km by road | None; Blue Line (due 2029) ends at Academic City, about 24 km by road |
| Golden Visa (AED 2 million) | Most apartments fall below it | Most homes are above it |
Sources: Emaar community and project pages (15 November 2026); Dubai Data’s DLD-derived registry and sales, data through 12 November 2026; dxbpropy.ai’s DLD sales and Ejari rents, 12 months to 11 November 2026; OpenStreetMap routing. Full list at the end. Prices change daily, so confirm with the developer.
Get today’s price list for both communities
Location and drive times
The two communities sit about 50 km apart, so the right one often comes down to where you work.
Emaar South is in Dubai South, next to Al Maktoum International Airport and in the same southern corridor as Expo City Dubai. Emaar names Sheikh Mohammed Bin Zayed Road (E311) as its main link to the city, and brokers also point to Emirates Road (E611).
The Valley is on the outer stretch of Dubai-Al Ain Road (E66), past Dubai Silicon Oasis, Academic City and Dubai Outlet Mall. Almost every trip starts on the E66.
We measured road distances from the middle of each community with OpenStreetMap routing:
| Destination | From Emaar South | From The Valley |
|---|---|---|
| Al Maktoum International Airport (DWC) terminal | 5 km, about 8 min | 50 km, about 45 min |
| Expo City Dubai (metro station) | 20 km, about 21 min | 41 km, about 40 min |
| Downtown Dubai (Burj Khalifa) | 53 km, about 45 min | 39 km, about 35 min |
| Dubai Marina (Marina Mall) | 38 km, about 34 min | 53 km, about 50 min |
| Dubai International Airport (DXB) Terminal 3 | 63 km, about 61 min | 43 km, about 45 min |
OpenStreetMap data via the public OSRM router, 15 November 2026. Times assume empty roads, so rush hour will be longer. Test your real commute at the hours you’d travel.
Emaar’s own pages quote shorter trips, such as 25 to 30 minutes from Emaar South to Downtown and about 25 minutes from The Valley to Downtown and DXB. Our measured distances are longer, so treat the marketing times as best-case.
The pattern is clear. Emaar South wins for anyone working at the airport, in Dubai South, at Expo City or in Dubai Marina. The Valley is closer to Downtown, DXB and the east of the city.
What can you buy, and for how much?
Property types
Emaar describes Emaar South as a mix of apartments, townhouses and villas around an 18-hole championship golf course. Its masterplan covers about 22,700 homes, including about 15,360 apartments. The newest releases, such as Golf Fields, Golf Vale and Golf Trails, are mostly one- to three-bedroom apartments with a few three-bedroom townhouses.
The Valley has no apartments. Emaar sells three- and four-bedroom townhouses, twin villas, and four- and five-bedroom villas. If you need a garden and your own front door, that narrows the choice quickly.
Prices Emaar lists today
Emaar shows two kinds of prices. A “starting price” or “prices from” figure is usually the launch price. A price marked “available now” with units remaining is live stock. Here is what Emaar’s community pages showed on 15 November 2026:
| Price on Emaar’s site | Emaar South | The Valley |
|---|---|---|
| Community “prices from” | AED 1,060,000 | AED 1,600,000 |
| Cheapest live listing | Golf Trails, 2 to 3 bedrooms, from AED 1,906,888 (14 units remaining) | Ovelle, 5 bedrooms, from AED 8,891,888 (5 units remaining) |
| Other live listings | Golf Vale from AED 1,987,888; Vista Ridge from AED 2,614,888; Grove Ridge from AED 2,626,888; Golf Hills 2 from AED 3,259,888 | None shown |
| Cheapest current townhouse launch price | Not applicable (townhouses sit inside apartment releases) | Venera and Velora from AED 2,480,000 |
Source: Emaar community pages for Emaar South and The Valley, 15 November 2026. Launch prices don’t confirm that units are still available.
So the headline gap of AED 1.06 million against AED 1.6 million understates the real difference. Emaar South still has new apartments on sale below AED 2 million. In The Valley, the only home with a live price on Emaar’s site costs nearly AED 8.9 million, so most buyers on a normal budget will be buying resale.
What buyers have actually paid
DLD records give a better picture than launch prices. Over the 12 months to October 2026:
- Emaar Dubai South DWC LLC, the Emaar company behind Emaar South, registered 1,567 sales at a median of AED 1.68 million and about AED 1,609 per sq ft. About 81% were off plan.
- The Valley registered 606 sales at a median of AED 3.30 million and about AED 1,376 per sq ft. About 41% were off plan.
Per home, Emaar South is about half the price. Per square foot, The Valley is cheaper. That’s the trade-off in one line: you pay less in The Valley for each square foot, but each home is much bigger.
For a like-for-like test, compare ready three-bedroom villas and townhouses. DLD sales over the last 12 months averaged AED 2.48 million in Emaar South and AED 2.70 million in The Valley. The Valley’s three-bedroom homes are also larger on average, at about 1,835 sq ft in rent contracts against about 1,555 sq ft in Emaar South.
Launch price vs registered price
Here is something most comparisons miss: what buyers paid next to the price Emaar launched at.
| Project | Emaar launch price | Registered median (DLD) | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Golf Vale (Emaar South) | From AED 1.09M | 1-bed AED 1.15M; all sales AED 1.56M | Most sales were near the entry level |
| Golf Fields (Emaar South) | From AED 1.26M | 1-bed AED 1.26M; all sales AED 1.61M | One-beds sold at the launch price |
| Golf Trails (Emaar South) | From AED 1.25M | 1-bed AED 1.26M; all sales AED 1.29M | Weighted to smaller units |
| Golf Hills (Emaar South) | From AED 1.06M | 1-bed AED 1.08M; all sales AED 1.54M | Entry price held for one-beds |
| Vindera (The Valley) | From AED 3.17M | AED 3.45M (337 sales) | Median sale about 9% above the entry price |
| Ovelle (The Valley) | From AED 7.09M | AED 7.29M (84 sales) | Close to launch |
| Elora (The Valley, now complete) | From AED 1.6M | Ready 3-bed resale AED 2.57M | Resale buyers today pay well above the original launch price |
Sources: Emaar project pages; Dubai Data DLD-derived project pages, data through 12 November 2026. Launch prices are entry points, and medians mix unit sizes, so a gap is not the same as price growth.
Two lessons stand out. In Emaar South, one-bedroom apartments in the new releases sold at or close to the launch price, so the advertised entry figure was real for early buyers. In The Valley, Elora’s AED 1.6 million launch price is now history: a ready three-bedroom there has a median resale price of AED 2.57 million.
Compare more Emaar releases on our Emaar new launches page and our list of the best off plan projects in Dubai.
Payment plans and handover
Payment plans
Both communities’ newest releases are marketed on a 10/70/20 plan: 10% on booking, 70% during construction and 20% on completion.
- Emaar South: Emaar-branded schedules for Golf Fields and Golf Vale, hosted by a broker, show this split. Golf Vale’s schedule takes the buyer to 80% paid by January 2029, with the final 20% due at completion, estimated for March 2030. Golf Trails’ split is reported by a broker.
- The Valley: Emaar’s pages don’t publish the plan. Found, a broker, reports 10/70/20 for Avelia and Ovelle (broker-reported).
Neither community’s newest releases are marketed with payments running after handover. If you need that, read our guide to post-handover payment plans in Dubai. For how these schedules work in general, see Dubai off plan payment plans explained.
How much cash you need upfront
Here are two realistic routes in, side by side.
| Cost | Emaar South: Golf Trails off plan at AED 1,906,888 | The Valley: ready 3-bed at AED 2,700,000 with a mortgage |
|---|---|---|
| Booking or deposit | AED 190,689 (10%) | AED 540,000 (20% minimum deposit) |
| DLD fee (4%) | AED 76,276 | AED 108,000 |
| Cash on day one | AED 266,964 | AED 648,000 |
| Later payments | AED 1,334,822 during construction, then AED 381,378 at completion | Monthly mortgage payments |
Illustrations only, before admin, agency and mortgage fees. The Golf Trails price is Emaar’s lowest live listing on 15 November 2026. The Valley figure is the average ready three-bedroom villa sale over 12 months. The 20% deposit is the Central Bank minimum for an expat’s first home under AED 5 million.
The off plan route needs less cash on day one. But you will have paid 80% of the price before you can live in it or rent it out. See our DLD fees guide and Dubai mortgage guide for the full costs.
Construction progress vs declared dates
Every project registered with DLD has a declared completion date and a construction figure from its last inspection. Putting the two side by side shows how much work is left.
| Project | Community | Built at last inspection | Declared completion |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vindera | The Valley | 2% | 31 Dec 2028 |
| Golf Hills and Golf Hills 2 | Emaar South | 4% | 30 Sep 2029 |
| Grove Ridge and Vista Ridge | Emaar South | 0% | 30 Sep 2029 |
| Ovelle | The Valley | 2% | 31 Dec 2029 |
| Golf Fields | Emaar South | 0% | 28 Feb 2030 |
| Golf Vale | Emaar South | 0% | 31 Mar 2030 |
| Golf Trails | Emaar South | 0% | 31 Oct 2030 |
Source: Dubai Data, DLD-derived registry, data through 12 November 2026. Inspections are irregular, so a low figure doesn’t mean work has stopped. Declared dates are registry fields, not handover promises.
Vindera stands out. It was 2% built at its last inspection, with a declared completion date about two years away. That doesn’t prove it will be late, but it is the date to question most closely before you buy there. Read our guide to property handover delays and check the project’s escrow account too.
The wider pipeline matters as well. In the DLD registry, Emaar South has 23 projects with 5,716 homes under construction, 13 of them under 5% built. The Valley has 21 projects with 6,790 homes under construction, 7 of them under 5% built. Both will add thousands of homes before today’s off plan buyers get their keys.
The Valley is further along in one way. Several of its clusters, such as Rivana (95%), Alana (82%) and Nima (80%), are close to complete, which gives buyers a nearer-term option than anything under construction in Emaar South’s newest releases.
Ask us for the latest construction report for any cluster
Rents and rental yields
Both communities have finished homes with registered tenancy contracts, so we can compare real rents from the same source.
| Home | Emaar South average rent | The Valley average rent |
|---|---|---|
| 2-bedroom apartment | AED 79,537 (414 contracts) | No apartments |
| 3-bedroom apartment | AED 104,831 (141 contracts) | No apartments |
| 3-bedroom villa or townhouse | AED 114,365 (421 contracts) | AED 134,938 (666 contracts) |
| 4-bedroom villa or townhouse | AED 150,601 (161 contracts) | AED 175,674 (230 contracts) |
| Gross yield | Villas about 4.3%; apartments about 5.2% | Villas about 4.9% |
Source: dxbpropy.ai, DLD Ejari contracts (new and renewed) starting in the 12 months to 11 November 2026, and DLD sales for yields. Dubai Data reports a similar 4.96% gross yield for The Valley.
The Valley’s three-bedroom homes rent for about AED 20,000 a year more, but they are also bigger. Per square foot, three-bedroom villa rents are about the same in both, at around AED 74.
A simple check on the ready three-bedroom averages gives the same picture: AED 114,365 on AED 2,480,000 is about 4.6% gross in Emaar South, and AED 134,938 on AED 2,700,000 is about 5.0% in The Valley.
Remember that new off plan homes have no rent record yet, and both communities will add thousands of homes by 2030. Gross yield is before service charges, fees and empty months.
Service charges
Dubai Data’s summary of DLD’s 2026 service charge rates lists a median of about AED 6.4 per sq ft a year across 5 Emaar South buildings. On a 1,500 sq ft home that is roughly AED 9,600 a year.
The Valley has no entry in that index. A broker quotes AED 3 to 4 per sq ft for Avelia, which is a broker estimate, not an official rate. For any home you’re serious about, ask for the latest invoice or the owners association’s approved budget.
Schools, shops and daily life today
This is where the two differ most for families.
Emaar South has its finished 18-hole golf course and clubhouse, parks and pools within projects. GEMS Founders School Dubai South, a British-curriculum school that opened in 2024, is about 0.9 km from the Greenview 1 cluster. KHDA’s directory lists it as not yet inspected.
The Valley has The Valley Pavilion on Al Ain Road, with a Monoprix supermarket, Bin Sina Pharmacy, Costa and a Maple Bear nursery. There is no school inside the community. The nearest KHDA schools, such as The Aquila School and GEMS FirstPoint School, are about 11 km away in a straight line. Emaar markets a beach, a sports village and a town centre, but brokers say parts haven’t opened, so visit and check.
An independent scoring by dxbpropy.ai, which counts schools, clinics, supermarkets, parks, malls and transport near homes, ranks Emaar South 129th and The Valley 134th out of 135 Dubai areas. In plain terms, both are car-first suburbs today.
Metro and roads
Neither community has a metro station.
- Emaar South: the nearest station is Expo City Dubai, about 20 km by road. Road access is via the E311 and E611.
- The Valley: the RTA’s Blue Line is due to open on 9 September 2029 and will end at Dubai Academic City, about 24 km by road from The Valley. Road access is the E66.
Plan on at least one car per household in either community.
Golden Visa: which homes clear AED 2 million?
The UAE’s property route to a Golden Visa needs property worth at least AED 2 million. This is where the two communities split sharply.
- In Emaar South, Emaar’s company registered half its sales below AED 1.68 million, and three quarters below about AED 2.28 million. Its two cheapest live listings, Golf Trails at AED 1,906,888 and Golf Vale at AED 1,987,888, both sit just under AED 2 million. Two-bedroom apartments had a median of about AED 1.84 million, so most one- and two-bedroom apartments fall below the threshold.
- In The Valley, three quarters of registered sales were above AED 2.75 million, so almost any home there clears the threshold.
Rules on off plan and mortgaged homes have changed, so read our UAE Golden Visa property guide and confirm with the authorities before you buy for residency.
Risks to weigh in each community
| Risk | Emaar South | The Valley |
|---|---|---|
| Construction | Newest releases 0% to 4% built, due 2029 to 2030 | Vindera 2% built with a 2028 declared date |
| Supply | 5,716 homes under construction in the registry; masterplan of about 22,700 | 6,790 homes under construction in the registry |
| Commute | Long drive to Downtown and DXB | Long drive to the Marina, Dubai South and the airport |
| Schools | One nearby school, not yet inspected | No school inside; nearest about 11 km |
| Resale | Many similar off plan apartments selling at once | Ready villa resale market with plenty of listings |
| Airport plans | Airport-led growth is planned, not guaranteed | Not dependent on the airport |
On resale, dxbpropy.ai’s listings feed showed about 1,505 homes for sale in The Valley in early November 2026, an average of 82 days on the market, and asking-price cuts outnumbering rises by about four to one since July. That suggests buyers there have room to negotiate.
Before you pay a deposit in either community, check the project’s Oqood registration and read our guide on how to avoid off plan scams.
Which should you choose? By buyer profile
First-time buyer with under AED 2 million
Emaar South is the realistic choice. New one-bedroom apartments in Golf Fields, Golf Trails and Golf Hills registered at medians of about AED 1.08 million to AED 1.26 million, and Emaar still lists live stock below AED 2 million. The Valley rarely offers anything at that level.
If you’d rather buy ready with a mortgage, check whether you qualify for the First-Time Home Buyer Programme.
Family wanting a townhouse or villa
The Valley gives more home for the money. Its ready three-bedroom villas averaged AED 2.70 million against AED 2.48 million in Emaar South, but they are about 18% larger on average, going by rent contracts, and the community has no apartments at all. Its weak point is schools.
Emaar South has townhouses and villas too, with a school nearby. If school runs matter more than space, it deserves a visit. Read our The Valley by Emaar guide and our Emaar South guide for every cluster.
Investor looking for rental yield
For gross yield, Emaar South apartments lead at about 5.2%, then villas in The Valley at about 4.9%, then villas in Emaar South at about 4.3%. A ready home earns rent now. An off plan home earns nothing until 2029 or 2030, and both communities will add new supply in the meantime.
If you want income now, a ready unit beats any of the new releases. Our guide to off plan vs ready property explains the trade-offs.
Commuting to the airport, Dubai South or Expo City
Emaar South, clearly. It is about 5 km from the Al Maktoum airport terminal and about 20 km from Expo City Dubai, against about 50 km and 41 km from The Valley. If you work in Downtown, DXB or the east of the city, the answer flips.
Tell us your budget and we’ll shortlist homes in both
Get a shortlist of homes in Emaar South and The Valley
Tell us your budget, preferred bedroom count, where you work and your timeline. A Dubai Livin property specialist will send you a shortlist of available homes in both communities, new and ready, with the latest prices and payment plans.
Final verdict: Emaar South or The Valley?
Emaar South is the budget pick and the commuter pick for the south of Dubai. It offers new Emaar apartments under AED 2 million, a golf course that’s already built and a school nearby, but its newest homes won’t be ready until 2029 or 2030.
The Valley is the space pick. It offers bigger townhouses and villas, higher villa rents and a deeper ready resale market, but at a higher price per home and with no school inside the community yet.
Whichever you choose, compare specific units on size, view, payment schedule and registered sale prices before you commit.
Compare available homes in Emaar South and The Valley
Frequently asked questions: Emaar South vs The Valley
Which is cheaper, Emaar South or The Valley?
Emaar South is cheaper per home because it sells apartments. Registered sales by Emaar’s Emaar South company had a median of AED 1.68 million over the last 12 months, against AED 3.30 million in The Valley. Per square foot The Valley is cheaper, at a median of about AED 1,376 against AED 1,609, because its homes are larger townhouses and villas.
Which is better for families, Emaar South or The Valley?
It depends on what the family needs. The Valley only has townhouses and villas, and its three-bedroom homes are larger on average. Emaar South has a British-curriculum school, GEMS Founders School Dubai South, about 0.9 km from its Greenview 1 cluster, while The Valley has no school inside the community and its nearest KHDA schools are about 11 km away.
Which has the better rental yield?
On registered Ejari rents and DLD sales, villas in The Valley yield about 4.9% gross and villas in Emaar South about 4.3%. Apartments in Emaar South yield about 5.2% gross. Net returns are lower once service charges, fees and empty months are taken off.
How far are Emaar South and The Valley from Al Maktoum airport and Expo City?
Emaar South is about 5 km by road from the Al Maktoum International Airport terminal and about 20 km from Expo City Dubai. The Valley is about 50 km from the airport and about 41 km from Expo City, based on OpenStreetMap routing.
Do Emaar South and The Valley have the same payment plan?
The newest releases in both are marketed on a 10/70/20 plan: 10% on booking, 70% during construction and 20% on completion. For Golf Fields and Golf Vale this comes from Emaar-branded schedules. For The Valley’s Avelia and Ovelle it is reported by a broker. Always check the schedule in your sale agreement.
When will the new homes be handed over?
DLD registry dates for Emaar South’s newest releases run from 30 September 2029 (Golf Hills, Grove Ridge and Vista Ridge) to 31 October 2030 (Golf Trails). In The Valley, Vindera’s declared completion is 31 December 2028 and Ovelle’s is 31 December 2029. Registry dates are not handover promises.
Can I get a Golden Visa by buying in Emaar South or The Valley?
The UAE property route needs property worth at least AED 2 million. Most homes in The Valley sell above that level, while most apartments in Emaar South sell below it. Check the current rules in our Golden Visa guide and with the authorities before you buy.
Is there a metro near Emaar South or The Valley?
Neither has a metro station. From Emaar South the nearest station is Expo City Dubai, about 20 km by road. The Blue Line, due to open on 9 September 2029, will end at Dubai Academic City, which is still about 24 km by road from The Valley.
Should I buy off plan or ready in these communities?
Off plan suits buyers who can wait until 2028 to 2030 and want to spread payments. Ready homes suit buyers who want to move in or rent out now. The Valley has the bigger ready resale market: about 41% of its registered sales were off plan, against about 81% for Emaar’s Emaar South company.
Research sources
- Emaar: Emaar South community page
- Emaar: The Valley community page
- Emaar: Golf Trails
- Emaar: Golf Vale
- Emaar: Golf Fields
- Dubai Data: Emaar Dubai South DWC LLC projects and sales (DLD-derived)
- Dubai Data: Emaar Development project registry (DLD-derived)
- Dubai Data: The Valley sales, rents and yields (DLD-derived)
- Dubai Data: Golf Fields, Golf Vale, Golf Trails, Golf Hills
- Dubai Data: The Valley – Vindera, Ovelle, Elora
- Dubai Data: Dubai service charges by community, 2026
- dxbpropy.ai: Emaar South prices and rents
- dxbpropy.ai: The Valley prices and rents
- Golf Vale payment plan (Emaar-branded PDF, broker-hosted)
- Golf Fields fact sheet (Emaar-branded PDF, broker-hosted)
- Found (broker): Avelia payment plan and Ovelle payment plan
- Propsearch: schools near Greenview 1 at Emaar South
- KHDA: GEMS Founders School Dubai South
- Cresco Real Estate (broker): The Valley area guide
- Emaar Malls: The Valley Pavilion
- Maple Bear Nursery: The Valley
- RTA: Dubai Metro Blue Line
- Central Bank of the UAE: mortgage loan ratios
- UAE Government portal: Golden visa
- OSRM router on OpenStreetMap data
Editorial disclaimer: Dubai Livin is an independent property research platform and is not the official website of Emaar Properties. This article provides general market information and does not constitute personalised investment or financial advice.